Department of Health

Website of the Department of Health

Please note that this website has a UK government access keys system.

You are here:

Special report on the Chairs' Conference 2003

A round-up of the national conference for chairs in September including a summary of the key speeches and the focus for the coming year.

Health secretary encourages patient champions

NHS chairs were urged to become 'patient champions' for their local communities by the health secretary.

John Reid urged chairs to uphold the traditional values of the NHS to ensure services were delivered to those who needed them most.

He said: "I see my role as doing three things: providing leadership, communicating and exercising judgement - it strikes me your role is very similar at a local level."

While chief executives do a great job, too often they are focused on balancing the books and managing waiting lists, he said.

"But there's an extra role chairs can perform by bringing a personal touch to the service so that patients feel they are truly at the centre of the way services are organised for their convenience - not for the interests of bureaucracy," he said.

Mr Reid stressed that a motivated workforce was vital to achieve this reform and he hoped chairs would also focus on ensuring that staff feel valued in their organisations.

At the heart of change

NHS chief executive Sir Nigel Crisp praised chairs as the drivers of change but called on them not to release their grip on improved service delivery.

"You and your chief executives have led your organisations successfully through a demanding period - together your results are impressive and give us all real confidence for the future.

"Without good governance led by you, we will not continue to make the changes that patients and the public want to see.

"Together you have brought waiting down across the whole system, from GPs to A&E, to hospitals and back to the community.

"What makes your performance even more rewarding is to get behind the figures and look at people - at the real long-term improvements in outcomes and life chances for individuals and society at large.

"NHS chairs are pivotal in helping people give out their best - your motivation and goodwill towards the NHS is very high.

"That is why, in Governing the NHS, we have put chairs and their boards at the heart of the change programme. Without good governance led by you, we will not continue to make the changes that patients and the public want to see."

For the remainder of the financial year, Sir Nigel said the focus will be on: sustaining pace on delivery; effective winter management; using choice to raise awareness of patient involvement; new staff contracts; value for money and bureaucracy; and the IT programme.

He said that sustaining progress was crucial.

Cutting bureaucracy

Stripping out outmoded red tape and sharing more resources will be key jobs for chairs over the coming year.

Sir Nigel Crisp said: "Locally, I am looking for all 600-plus NHS organisations to tackle this on two fronts. First, to strip out outmoded bureaucratic steps for staff, patients and users - to exploit and redesign new IT and prescribing systems for example - to free up professional and administrative time and avoid the 'care paper chase'.

"Second, to reduce local overheads - by sharing more backroom support functions, by sharing management resources and by setting yourselves demanding challenges on reducing overheads."

Sir Nigel added that the Department of Health was undergoing the same exercise.

"I am committed to reducing the national overhead - as I am doing in re-orientating the work of my own department and reducing its size, by enforcing a tight gateway process and by working with other national bodies to streamline regulation and data collection.

"This is high profile - you and I need to account for this to the public - and explain what we are doing."

The challenge of GP recruitment

The challenge of recruiting more GPs into the NHS was raised by chairs at the conference.

One chair said the pressures under which GPs were working and the challenges PCTs face in replacing them was being underestimated by the department.

"It is a major challenge - many of us are not balking from it but I think we would be rash to underestimate just how great a challenge it is," he said.

Rural areas faced similar problems, another chair added.

A chairman from the north told the conference that his area was facing a 'double whammy' in terms of GP recruitment problems.

"There is already a very acute shortage of GPs and, on the other hand, we are dealing with acute disinvestment and a really high level of prevalence of health inequalities.

"We have tried, in collaboration with other PCTs in our area, to go as far afield as Spain - recently we were able to recruit about five.

"I don't want to deprive some of the developing countries of their GPs but I think simply to restrict recruitment to the EU countries is not going to be successful."

Responding, Sir Nigel Crisp highlighted the high number of GPs with a special interest - 30 per cent - at one Bradford PCT which was cutting hospital waiting lists dramatically.

"I think you just need to continue to look at how you can actually build the reputation among the GP community that the NHS is a good place to work and how you can put the support in to make that happen."

He said that chairs should learn from leaders of other successful organisations and services to see how they attract and retain quality staff.

But he also acknowledged that more could be done nationally, particularly in recruiting people from abroad.

Governing the NHS

Governing the NHS - a Guide for NHS Boards should be used to improve the quality of non-executives in the future

The guide, developed by the NHS Appointments Commission and the Department of Health, was drawn up taking account of the experience of chairs, non-executive directors and senior managers.

The aim is to reinforce the importance of good governance and strategic leadership at a time of major reform in the NHS. Commission chair Sir William Wells said the response to the guide had been very positive.

"It is a very important document - for the first time it sets out governance in the NHS and the inter-relationship between all the various organisations.

"It makes the role of non-executives much clearer. What I want to do, with your help, is to use that to improve the quality of non executives in the future - the role has changed very dramatically and is continuing to change," he said.

One chair said non-executives helped trusts maintain direction while guarding against complacency.

"It is about giving an input and being one of the catalysts to maintaining good performance," he said.

Governing the NHS - a Guide for NHS Boards is at:

The last Non-Exec Bulletin contained a detailed report on the new guide and is available at:

Winter challenges

Tackling the problem of hospital-acquired infections is a key part of ensuring that effective winter NHS services are delivered.

The onset of winter traditionally puts great pressure on the NHS with an increasing demand for services.

Sir Nigel Crisp called for action from chairs, particularly on hospital infections.

"We need to make sure that we continue our excellent record on working with social services and the voluntary sector through winter and managing the inevitable pressures which arise.

"This year, we need to pay more attention to the risks of hospital-associated infection - we need to act."

The Department of Health, he added, would be producing a report on winter services shortly before Christmas.

Leadership opportunities

A national leadership programme has been developed to enable boards to tap into the widest range of NHS talent in making new appointments.

NHS Leadership Centre director Penny Humphris said: "Eventually we will be able to monitor leadership talent right across the NHS so, over time, we will get even better at knowing where that future talent lies.

"As chairs, you all know, perhaps only too well, the challenges that you face in recruiting a new chief executive, executive or non-executive director.

"Our aim is that NHS Leaders will help you find those people who are already within the NHS, who fit your requirement and who are ready and keen to move onto a new challenge."

NHS Leaders helps individuals manage their own development; makes non-executive directors and senior leaders responsible for supporting this development; and enables boards to draw on the widest range of NHS talent in making appointments.

More information at:

NHS Executive Search

NHS Executive Search is a new service connecting 13 of the best executive search companies with NHS organisations.

It is available to all NHS organisations in England and aims to help them match the right people with the right jobs.

Full details of the service were presented to delegates.

A project manager is available to act as an interface between the NHS and the providers of executive search services.

As a guide, each NHS organisation employs a chief executive and between five and seven board-level executive directors.

The turnover of these post holders is, on average, one executive post per organisation per year.

The executive search service helps NHS organisations to match suitable applicants to highly demanding leadership roles within the NHS, including chief executive, finance, IT and HR director appointments.

The service will save organisations time and money usually spent in lengthy tendering and contracting processes.

Full details of NHS Executive Search are at:

NHS Live 2004

NHS Live 2004 is a planned three-day event designed to showcase the very best that the NHS has to offer.

Featuring key speakers, exhibitions, masterclasses and workshops, it is being held at London's Docklands from 5-7 July.

About 4,500 people are expected to attend each day of the event, which aims to promote best practice across the health service and support and drive local improvements.

More details about NHS Live will be available in due course.

Making a difference

An overwhelming majority of NHS chairs believe they have made a substantial difference to services over the past year.

And just under half of those questioned at the conference think staff morale has improved significantly during the same period.

Compere Nick Ross was asking the questions to which the 450 delegates responded using electronic keypads. The questions and responses follow (all figures are expressed in percentages):

Have things got better or worse in the last year in your area?

Palpably better: 60
Worse: 15

I have made a substantial difference on improving things in my area over the last year:

Agree: 64
Disagree: 5
Hard to say: 31

Who are you representing today?

Primary care trust: 46
Mental health or priority services trust: 9
Acute trust: 25
Special health authority: 8
Strategic health authority: 5
Ambulance trust: 4
Other: 3

What special skills do you bring?

People skills: 36
Performance scrutiny: 18
Detailed knowledge of local community: 10
Excellence networks with other agencies (i.e. local government and voluntary sector): 15
Something else (i.e. knowledge of running a large organisation): 17

Is your part of the NHS delivering better care than it was a year ago?

Yes (for some): 58
Yes (for most): well over one third
No: 3

Are your organisation's clinical outcomes:

Measurably improved: 30
Same: 29
Worse: 0
Not yet measured sufficiently to make a judgement: 41

Is your patient and user experience getting better or not?

Measurably improved on last year: 38
Expectations growing faster than we can move: 30
Same: 19
Not measured sufficiently to judge it: 12
Worse: 1

Is staff morale more positive than this time last year?

Yes: 46
Same: 32
Worse: 20
Difficult to say: 2

Access keys