30 pc reduction in admissions could mean people don't spend unnecessary time in hospital and save over £400m a year for other services
Improving health services by cutting unnecessary emergency admissions could help the NHS save over £400 million a year, Health Secretary Patricia Hewitt said today.
She published new figures from the NHS Institute for Innovation and Improvement to illustrate how the NHS could improve its services for people, reduce the interruptions of unnecessary emergency admissions on people's lives and improve value for money. She also published best practice examples from the NHS to highlight what can be done.
The NHS spends around £1.3bn a year on admissions for patients with 18 common ailments - known as 'ambulatory care sensitive' conditions - such as asthma, angina and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. These unplanned admissions are extremely worrying for the people concerned and their families and disrupt their lives.
The most frequent admissions - those patients who repeatedly call on emergency care services and are often admitted to hospital three times or more during a year - are often for one of these 18 conditions.
Such emergencies account for a large proportion of total hospital admissions, and this varies enormously from area to area. In some regions, it is less than 10 per cent of hospital costs and in others it rises to nearly 25 per cent.
Ms Hewitt said that better management of these patients' conditions in a community setting could improve their lives, reduce emergency hospital admissions and reduce costs - especially for those Primary Care Trusts (PCTs) where unplanned emergency admissions account for a larger than average proportion.
She said:
'Some people with long term conditions experience their lives as going from one emergency hospital admission to another.
'Whilst it's important to know the hospital is always there, it's a much better, more stable life for people if they can be treated in the community without the need for so many emergencies.
'Everything we can do to diminish this will improve people's lives. Having so many unplanned admissions can also make it harder to develop day-to-day services in the hospital and increase costs. More efficient community treatment and better assessment processes can avoid the need for hospitalisation.'
She said there was a lot more that some parts of the NHS could do to improve productivity and efficiency.
'If we could cut these unplanned emergency admissions by 30 per cent, patients would have improved lives, hospitals would be able to plan their services better and the NHS could achieve savings of over £400m a year.
'The potential savings from those PCTs that have many more emergency admissions than the average is almost £2.5m per PCT.'
The 18 common conditions where community treatment can reduce costs include chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (over 106,000 admissions costing £253m a year), angina (almost 80,000 admissions costing more £134m), asthma (over 61,000 admissions costing £64m) and the skin complaint cellulitis (over 45,000 admissions costing £87m).
Recommendations from the NHS Institute for Innovation and Improvement outline areas on which the NHS should focus to reduce emergency care costs, including:
Patricia Hewitt added:
'Trusts with a high proportion of unplanned emergency care admissions and a high proportion with a length of stay of less than two days have the potential to reduce this with better assessment processes and improved primary care management of patients.
'The NHS is in receipt of record funding. Better patient care has been the result, with waiting lists at record lows, more doctors and nurses than ever before, a world-class A&E service and huge reductions in death from the big killer diseases. But we have a duty to the taxpayer as well as the patient to ensure we get more value for this extra money.
'Reforms like practice based commissioning, where GPs and other primary care professionals are more involved in commissioning care for patients in the community, can help reduce costs and the burden on emergency services as well as providing more accessible care for patients.'
In Dudley, west Midlands, PCTS have developed new care-closer-to-home pathways for patients, by redesigning clinical roles. Clinician to clinician communication has been improved so that patients have a seamless transfer through their whole episode of care, with services developed to prevent unnecessary hospital admission.
Stan Doman, 68, from Lodge Farm Estate in Dudley, suffers from a number of conditions including emphysema and angina. For the last twelve months, he's been cared for by nurse consultant Cath Molineux.
Stan said:
"Cath is always on hand if I have any questions. Over the last six years I've been in and out of hospital around five times a year but last year I only went in once. Being at home actually makes me feel better - in hospital you have less freedom to decide what you eat and when you have a bath. At home I can please myself."
Cath Molineux, said:
"Not all patients need to keep going into hospital, and by visiting them at home we can monitor their condition and anticipate any problems they may have. By working in partnership with social care colleagues we can ensure our patients get the best care possible. This way we help reduce overcrowding in our hospital - helping them to focus on providing care for patients who really need it."
1) Table of emergency admissions by ambulatory care sensitive condition 2003/04 (Source NHS Institute)
| CATEGORY OF ADMISSION | No. OF EPISODES | COST IN £m |
|---|---|---|
| Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) | 106,517 | 253 |
| Angina (without major procedure) | 79,228 | 134 |
| Ear, Nose and Throat infections (ENT) | 72,831 | 52 |
| Convulsions and epilepsy | 64,664 | 77 |
Congestive heart failure | 62,582 | 211 |
| Asthma | 61,264 | 64 |
| Flu and pneumonia (>2 months old) | 56,616 | 158 |
| Dehydration and gastroenteritis | 54,402 | 96 |
| Cellulitis(without major procedure) | 45,522 | 87 |
| Diabetes with complications | 17,686 | 42 |
| Pyelonephritis | 8,469 | 13 |
Iron-deficiency anaemia | 8,268 | 20 |
| Perforated/bleeding ulcer | 7,327 | 26 |
| Dental conditions | 6,207 | 8 |
| Hypertension | 5,379 | 9 |
| Gangrene | 5,309 | 32 |
| Pelvic inflammatory disease | 5,070 | 9 |
| Vaccine preventable conditions | 2,326 | 5 |
| TOTAL | 669,720 | 1,295 |
2) Case studies
The Dudley PCTs have developed new care-closer-to-home pathways for patients, by redesigning clinical roles. The project shows how clinicians can be engaged in service redesign and how better patient education and information about services can influence changes in behaviour.
Health and social care workers have been brought together to provide high quality care in a seamless way. Improved information about services and better patient education has led to patients making more informed choices about their care.
In July of 2003, the PCT's professional executive committee chair (a GP), the Director of Quality and Nursing and a senior team manager in Social Services spent three days speaking to clinicians and patients in Dudley Hospital about the ways that they could work together to ensure that the patients received appropriate care at all times.
The reaction was overwhelming. Two main issues emerged. Firstly that clinician to clinician communication needed to be improved to ensure that patients had a seamless transfer through their whole episode of care. Secondly , although local services had been developed to prevent unnecessary hospital admission, this had not been communicated to front line clinicians in a way that maximised their use.
The team developed an action plan for the health and social care community which included a whole system clinical development programme leading to the development of a new model of care for Dudley.
This model provides a way forward for every health and social care economy in the country to use evidenced based care, coupled with innovative ways of using staff, to provide the best care for patients in a way that ensures that there is proper clinical engagement.
Benefits:
The Adam Practice in Dorset developed a primary care Echo service with cross-PCT coverage in the Poole area covering a population of over 170,000 (Echo is an in house testing echocardiology service for congestive heart failure diagnosis). A GPswSI runs the service with support from a qualified medical technical officer and a service manager/clerk. Each Echo costs about a quarter of the cost of a secondary care referral, which offsets the initial start-up cost fairly rapidly.
GP Dr Liddiard, who runs the scheme with a clinical assistant in cardiology, says: 'There are some real benefits for patients in running a primary care Echo service, with more patients having Echos and more people needing treatment being found. Treatment can be changed appropriately and cardiology time can be saved for patients with more sever morbidity.
Central Cornwall PCT has taken a whole system approach to the management of long-term conditions. Community matrons are working alongside GPs in the EPIC practices. The GPs and their teams have been able to rapidly access services via the community matron who has a workstation within the practice and access to the patients records. Practices report far greater co-ordination of care and access to services. They particularly value the monitoring role of their elderly patients.
Using a benefits realisation format they have been able to demonstrate a reduction in emergency admissions of 457 across Cornwall, the facilitation of 84 early discharges, reduced GP visit s in and out of hours, and increased patient satisfaction, generating savings of £975,000.
The Sharma practice near Grimsby had a high proportion of housebound patients on its chronic disease register. A nurse practitioner has the role of visiting and monitoring these conditions and may also undertake acute visits for the same cohort of patients. The nurse has also developed relationships with colleagues in community nursing and social services. Direct access for the nurse to step up care has been negotiated operating alongside a rigorous system of examining data on emergency admissions. This allows targeted and focussed intervention on those frequently admitted. For COPD the patient admission rates have been cut by 87 per cent, with none of those patients being admitted through A&E.
In 18 months a practice within the Forest of Dean has achieved a reduction in hospital admissions of 50 per cent (real figures 37 down to 17). The practice has introduced a regime of treating patients who report the first signs of an exacerbation by treating with steroids and antibiotics. Patients are also given an emergency supply to take at home if needed and agree a self-management plan.
3) Reducing repeat admissions was a key priority in the 2004 NHS Improvement Plan. The NHS is working towards a target of reducing emergency bed days by 5 per cent by 2008 through improved care in primary and community settings. Improved proactive care of patients has resulted in two per cent fewer Emergency Bed Days during 2004/05 has already released over £200m for additional patient treatments. Last year, the Department overhauled the way in which the NHS cares for people with long term conditions with better monitoring and management of people closer to home, backed up by the recruitment of 3000 community matrons. The recent White Paper announced a fundamental shift in expenditure from spending on hospitals to spending on care closer to home and on preventative services. It recognised that same procedure in primary care can cost as little as one-third compared to secondary care. There are over 15 million people in England living with a long term condition.
4) For media enquiries only contact 020 7210 5221 (out of hours 07050 073 581). For all other enquiries contact 020 7210 4850.